Disclosure: We may earn a commission or fee from some of the links in our content. However, this does not affect our recommendations. Learn more.
One of the most common reasons Shopify businesses fail — whether it’s dropshipping or print on demand — is poor product research.
I’ve worked with hundreds of ecommerce stores over the years, and the pattern is always the same.
Sellers launch a product based on instinct or opinion instead of actual demand, and then wonder why it doesn’t convert.
In this guide, I’ll walk through how I approach product research — what tools work, what data actually matters, and how to validate demand before any money is spent.
Whether you’re advising clients or managing research for a team, this process will save time, money, and frustration.
Why Product Research Is the Most Important Step
Before a single ad runs or a Shopify theme is installed, product research should already be complete.
The biggest misconception in ecommerce is that success starts with branding, design, or ad creatives. That’s backwards.
A solid product is the foundation.
The right product will:
- Create natural demand without forcing the sale
- Make ads cheaper (better clickthrough, higher engagement)
- Improve conversion rates without needing complex funnels
- Reduce refund and chargeback rates
Without this foundation, everything else becomes expensive and inefficient.
What Makes a Winning Product for Dropshipping and Print on Demand?
There’s a clear difference between “good” products and profitable products. The latter hits multiple points — not just aesthetic or novelty.
Here’s the framework I use to assess product viability for both models:
Dropshipping Product Criteria
| Metric | Ideal Range |
|---|---|
| Retail Price | $15–$45 |
| Product Cost | 25–35% of retail |
| Problem-Solving | Clear, visual benefit |
| Shipping | Lightweight, under 1lb |
| Saturation | Fewer than 5 direct competitors with active ads |
Print on Demand Product Criteria
| Factor | Best Practice |
|---|---|
| Target Audience | Passionate niche (pets, teachers, gamers, etc.) |
| Design | Identity-driven, emotional, or humorous |
| Product Types | Apparel, mugs, posters, tumblers |
| Personalization | Increases conversion by 30–40% |
| Seasonality | Consider both evergreen and holiday tie-ins |
Where to Look for Winning Product Ideas (Real-World Strategy)
Most successful product ideas don’t come from software — they come from attention.
In practice, I spend more time studying where people engage online than analyzing charts.
Here’s where I consistently find high-performing product angles.
TikTok and Instagram Reels
Short-form video platforms have become real-time focus groups.
To use them for research:
- Search tags like
#TikTokMadeMeBuyIt,#AmazonFinds, or niche-specific ones like#KitchenGadgets - Look for videos with organic engagement (100k+ views, real comments)
- Focus on products that are demonstrated visually — these perform better in ads
If a product consistently gets “Where can I get this?” comments, it’s worth adding to a shortlist.
Facebook Ad Library
Facebook’s ad transparency tool is one of the best ways to see what’s currently working.
When researching products:
- Search industry keywords (e.g. “pain relief”, “dog leash”, “funny mug”)
- Check how long an ad has been running — ads live 30+ days often signal profitable campaigns
- Look at the creative style — are they showing the product in action within 3 seconds?
This doesn’t just show product demand — it gives insight into marketing angles that convert.
Amazon Best Sellers and Movers & Shakers
Amazon’s public bestseller lists are useful for spotting trends that have moved from early stage to mass market.
I analyze:
- High-velocity products in consumer categories
- Product review patterns (what people love and hate)
- Gaps in design, bundle opportunities, or new feature sets
Print on demand sellers can use this to develop new product angles that mimic what’s already proven.
Using Data Tools to Strengthen Research
There are a lot of product research tools in the ecommerce space. After testing most of them, here’s what I recommend based on consistent performance.
| Tool | Use Case | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|
| Sell The Trend | Trend tracking for dropshipping | Pulls real-time product + ad data, including TikTok engagement |
| Ecomhunt | Early-stage dropshipping validation | Great filters by niche, price, and saturation |
| AutoDS | Research + fulfillment database | Speeds up product testing workflows |
| Niche Scraper | POD + dropshipping analysis | Competitive insights with AliExpress integration |
| Pinterest Trends | Seasonal discovery | Ideal for POD gift research |
| Google Trends | Keyword demand tracking | Validates search demand pre-launch |
Any of these can work as part of a lean research stack.
The key is not using them in isolation — always cross-reference what tools suggest with real customer behavior on social platforms.
Product Research for Print on Demand
Print on demand requires a different lens than dropshipping. It’s less about function and more about expression.
Customers aren’t buying a mug or shirt — they’re buying how it makes them feel, or how it signals identity to others.
Here’s how I help clients identify strong POD angles.
Start with Niche Identity
Successful POD designs are niche-first, not product-first. Start by answering:
- Who is the customer?
- What do they believe in or joke about?
- What kind of designs resonate with their subculture?
The more specific, the better. A shirt that says “Nurse Life” might sell, but a shirt that says “I’m a night shift ER nurse — I’ve seen some things” will connect on a deeper level.
Personalization Increases Conversion
If there’s one tactic that consistently improves performance in POD, it’s personalization.
Here are product types that lend themselves well:
- Mugs with pet names or birthdays
- Canvas prints with names and dates
- T-shirts that allow name or year customization
Platforms like Printify, Printful, and Gelato now offer simple personalization tools.
And these personalized products usually allow for higher pricing and lower return rates.
Use Etsy + Pinterest for Design Validation
Both platforms are full of proven demand signals for POD:
- On Etsy, look at top-selling products in each niche, especially those marked as “Bestseller”
- On Pinterest, search relevant terms and monitor what designs are consistently pinned
This doesn’t mean copying — it means understanding the types of designs and phrases that already connect with a buying audience.
How to Validate Demand Before Launching
Before spending anything on ads or production, I always recommend a basic demand validation phase.
This is how I help clients avoid launching products with no market fit.
Practical Validation Steps
- Reddit Polling: Ask communities directly (without links) what design or product they’d buy
- Run Small-Scale Spark Ads on TikTok: $20 tests can show engagement signals
- Use Klaviyo or Mailchimp to collect pre-orders: Launch with a “Coming Soon” waitlist page to measure early interest
- Monitor competitor reviews: Look for consistent praise or complaints that suggest strong product-market fit
Even with $0 ad spend, it’s possible to get reliable demand signals before scaling.
Common Product Research Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
After years of consulting and reviewing hundreds of failed stores, these are the mistakes I see most often.
Mistakes to Watch For
- Picking products based on personal preference rather than data
- Skipping saturation checks — if 10 stores are running the same ad, it’s too late
- Launching without seasonal planning — e.g. running Valentine’s gifts in March
- Not understanding their customer’s real problem — surface-level research only
- Over-relying on AliExpress or one supplier — limits product flexibility
Effective product research is about removing emotion from the process. Use data, behavior, and timing to guide decisions.
Final Thoughts: Product Research Is a Skill, Not a Guess
Product research isn’t luck. It’s a repeatable skill that improves with experience, attention to behavior, and smart use of data.
Every winning Shopify store I’ve worked with — whether dropshipping or print on demand — succeeded because the product was validated, timely, and positioned with the right audience in mind.
None of them got lucky.
If you’re running research for your team, coaching clients, or building your own ecommerce strategy, focus first on the product. Marketing, fulfillment, and scale only matter if the product is worth selling.
Mastering product research for Shopify is the best investment you can make in 2025.
